Who's fault is it really?: Josie, Scott or Amanda?

[WillowsTara]

Okay, this been on my mind for a long time since the baby had been discovered and since Scott found out that Amanda hid the baby results from him.

Now it is part of Amanda's fault for hiding it, but then again she was in love and didn't want Scott to know he was going to have a child, or he would have gone for Hayley instead.

But!, we all know that Scott ripped up the letter that Josie wrote to him. In the letter, Josie had written about the baby and was telling Scott that the baby was his,. not Kim's. And Josie couldn't tell him because well Josie wouldn't let him.

All for what? because Josie had a one night stand? I can name a dozen of the Summer Bay residents who cheated on each other and didn't have the whole bay against her or him. (Kirsty, Nick, Jesse, Flynn, Leah, Dan, Drew, Belle, Matidlia, Ric etc).

So it was in fact Scott's stubbornness that gotten in the way, if Scott had given Josie a chance, just to hear her out or read the letter then the whole story wouldn't have been dragged on for months.

Of course, the WHOLE thing is actually Zoey's/Eve's fault because she the one who switched the results in the first place (Did thet ever find out it was Zoey's fault to begin with? Or that Josie had told Scott about it in the letter).

Now if I was Hayley, Kim or Josie, I would have slapped him one if I discovered that Scott had the answer right in his hands, and completely ripped it up. (And if I was Leah, I would slap him and tell him "I told you it could have been something important!), I actually hoped Josie would come back and ask Scott, or Hayley if they read the letter and then Hayley would find out Scott had destroyed the answer and all.

But, who fault do you really think it is (Aside from Zoey/Eve) that the results hadn't been figured out until around the baby was born?

[emmasi]

Actually it was Kim and Hayley's fault for betraying Zoe. I think she actually quite liked them until they stabbed her in the back by sleeping together, her boyfriend and her best friend. Scott just got in the way

EDIT: Ohhh the results. Well yeah, I'll go with Scott. He can't get out of this without any blame

[WillowsTara]

Hmm, I didn't think of that, so do you think if Kim hadn't betrayed her, Zoey wouldn't have gone on her ramage? Or Kim may have actually been the one who have could have stopped her if Zoey really liked him for real (Then she must be a bisexual because wasn't she also with Sarah/Tracey?)

[Drew]

Zoe was already on her rampage when this storyline started, this was just one of those things that got in her way and she wanted to make people pay. I don't see Amanda being the fault in all of this because she came to the Bay in the late stages of all of this. It's Josie's fault for not telling Scott in person and not calling him afterwards, wondering if he read the letter. It's also Scott's fault for being an idiot and being so stubborn. He's like Martha without boobs.

[emmasi]

Hmm, I didn't think of that, so do you think if Kim hadn't betrayed her, Zoey wouldn't have gone on her ramage? Or Kim may have actually been the one who have could have stopped her if Zoey really liked him for real (Then she must be a bisexual because wasn't she also with Sarah/Tracey?)

No no no, I just mean that she wouldn't have done the paternity switch. Everything else she totally would have done.

As to her sexuality, I like the idea that she was really into Kim. That scene where she said "I've only ever loved one other person" just felt too personal and real to be a complete put on.